Arthritis Foundation Logo
Español ES
Your Local Area
Sign In
Popular Search
arthritis gout home ja
Suggested Content
Article
Rx for Access
Online resource that helps patients better understand health coverage options, choose the right coverage, manage the denial process and reduce health care costs.
Article
Do I Have Arthritis?
Think you may have arthritis? Learn about the four most common warning signs.
Article
Gout
Gout is an inflammatory type of arthritis that can come and go.
Arthritis Foundation Logo
  • About Arthritis
    Common Topics
    woman holding her wristWhat Is Arthritis?

    Arthritis is not one disease. Learn about the different types of arthritis, how they differ and why it’s important.

    microbesInflammation and the Immune System

    Body-wide inflammation is at the root of most chronic diseases — and you may have more control over it than you think.

    Patient talking with nurseNewly Diagnosed With Arthritis

    A new arthritis diagnosis can be overwhelming. These tips can help.

    • Understanding Arthritis
    • Arthritis Types
    • More About Arthritis
    • Where it Hurts
    • Related Conditions
  • Treatments
    Common Topics
    Woman holding shoulderWebinar: Touch Therapies for Pain Management

    Learn the evidence behind popular touch therapies for arthritis, including what to try and what to avoid, for how long and when.

    Managing Arthritis Care Costs

    Learn the basics about health care costs and financial tools available to you.

    Man with head in hands on bedWebinar: Arthritis Fatigue Causes and Solutions

    Learn the various causes of arthritis-related fatigue and strategies to combat weariness.

    • Treatment Plan
    • Drug Guide
    • Joint Surgery
    • Complementary Therapies
    • Insurance Management
  • Healthy Living
    Common Topics
    Woman with upset stomachMicrobiome, Gut Health & Arthritis

    Microbiome, microbes, microorganisms – these terms may be confusing, but the types of bacteria living in and on our bodies can impact arthritis. Learn what helps or harms the microbiome and the health of your gut and discover dietary changes that can make a difference. This episode was originally released on January 19, 2021.

    man exercisingStairs Workout Demo

    Strengthen your leg muscles and improve your stability to make going up and down stairs safer and easier.

    woman consoling anotherArthritis and Mental Health

    Learn about the connection between arthritis, depression and anxiety and how these conditions can make your arthritis worse.

    • Ease of Use Products
    • Managing Pain
    • Recipes & Nutrition
    • Physical Activity
    • Emotional Well-being
    • Daily Living
    • Family & Relationships
  • Juvenile Arthritis
    Common Topics
    2023 JA Family Summit

    Learn about the National Juvenile Arthritis Conference, a place for families to connect, share and learn.

    JA Camps

    The Arthritis Foundation’s JA camp programs give kids with arthritis and related childhood rheumatic diseases the chance to make lasting memories.

    Juvenile Arthritis Volunteer

    • About Juvenile Arthritis
    • Treatment
    • Managing Pain
    • Medical Decisions
    • Nutrition
    • Emotional Well-being
  • Professionals
    Common Topics
    Transforming Clinical Interactions

    The Live Yes! Arthritis community connects patients with others online and in-person for support and education, and encourages patients to play an active role in their health care.

    Partners 4 Patients with Arthritis

    The Arthritis Foundation recently launched an initiative to build stronger relationships and increase recognition of our most engaged practices. 

    Fellowships

    See how we're aiming to address the growing shortage of arthritis specialists, especially in under-served parts of the country.

    • Better Living Toolkits
    • Our Issue Briefs
  • Science
    Common Topics
    OACS Forum Series

    The Osteoarthritis Clinical Studies Forum Series features OA thought leaders from across the globe discussing the future of how the disease can be treated to improve patient outcomes.

    man bandaging boy's kneeConquering Childhood Arthritis

    The Arthritis Foundation is mobilizing patients and their families to engage in studies comparing the effectiveness of treatments for juvenile arthritis and funding research for more options.

    Focus

    • Awards
    • Funding Opportunities
    • OACS Forum Series
    • Osteoarthritis Focus
    • Participate in Clinical Trials
    • Partnerships
    • Publications
  • Get Involved
    Common Topics
    Capital hillAction Center

    Take action today - use the resources here to learn who your elected officials are, what opportunities we have to advocate from the comfort of your own home, federal and state legislation, and more!

    LiveYes! Insights thumbnailLive Yes! INSIGHTS

    Share your experience in a 10-minute assessment to be among those changing the future of arthritis.

    woman listening to podcastLive Yes! Podcast

    You may have arthritis, but it doesn't have you. The Arthritis Foundation’s one-of-a-kind podcast. Hosted by patients, for patients.

    • Advocacy
    • Ways to Give
    • Fundraising
    • Volunteer
    • Partnership
    • Live Yes! Arthritis Community
Donate
Back

The Future of OA Therapies

Experts focus on the challenges and promise of cell-based therapies to treat osteoarthritis.

By Jill Tyrer | Nov. 19, 2021

When you’ve done everything your doctor suggests to ease your joint pain and nothing seems to help enough, the promise of an injection that might ease pain, let you resume activities you love, delay surgery — and maybe even repair your damaged joint — sounds very appealing. So it’s understandable why so many clinics have popped up offering so-called “stem cell” therapies that promise to relieve arthritis and a range of other diseases.

However, there are no stem cell therapies approved to be sold legally in the U.S. for joint diseases because none have proven safe and effective for arthritis and related problems.

But that doesn’t mean researchers don’t see promise in such cellular-based, biological therapies, or regenerative medicine, for orthopedic conditions.

A recent Osteoarthritis Clinical Studies (OACS) Forum, titled “Cellular Therapies in OA,” brought together thought leaders in the field to discuss research challenges of these kinds of biological therapies, the role of rules and regulations, plus potential pathways forward and how the Arthritis Foundation might facilitate that process. Leading international experts, including investigators, clinicians and industry and regulatory experts took part in the November forum.

“Cellular Therapies” Today

The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) — which is charged with vetting drugs and medical treatments for safety and for effectiveness — has approved certain types of cellular-based therapies to treat cancers and a few other conditions. And some do have promise for orthopedic conditions, but the marketing has gotten ahead of the science, especially for osteoarthritis (OA).

One of the challenges is defining exactly what they are, because there is vast variation in what cells are harvested, how they’re harvested, the patients they’re harvested from, and how they’re processed. And the presence and potency of actual stem cells — which can develop into other types of cells, such as bone or blood cells — is not uniform. They might be derived from the patient’s own blood, bone marrow, skin or fat, for example. Often, the stem cells are present in such minute quantities that it’s not clear that they are the active ingredient, says forum moderator and orthopedic surgeon George Muschler, MD, professor of orthopedic Surgery and Biomedical Engineering and director of the Regenerative Biology Laboratory at Cleveland Clinic.

“Stem cells [sound] hot and sexy and have a tremendous appeal in the patient population. They come in and ask for stem cell therapy,” says Scott Bruder, MD, PhD, a pharmaceutical consultant, adjunct professor of orthopedic surgery and biomedical engineering at Case Western Reserve University and former member of the FDA Advisory Panel on Cell, Tissue and Gene Therapy. However, he adds, “It is a slippery slope and a dangerous position for clinicians and institutes to be advocating and promoting stem cell therapy, because there are no stem cell-approved products in orthopedics.”

Scientists are working with different formulations of biological therapies, such as bone-marrow aspirate concentrate (BMAC), induced pluripotent stem cells (IPSC) and platelet-rich plasma (PRP). Some of these do actually seem to relieve joint symptoms according to early reports, but none have been proven to repair joints, which is what patients often expect.

“I try to make a distinction between symptom modification and structure modification. That is, many of these therapies can treat symptoms to varying degrees but we do not have much data to support they’re truly structure-modifying, that is, that they can regenerate tissue,” says Scott Rodeo, MD, orthopedic surgeon and director of the Center for Regenerative Medicine at Hospital for Special Surgery, professor of orthopedic surgery at Weill Cornell Medical College and head team physician for the New York Giants Football.

But OA has few effective treatments, and after someone has followed the recommended therapies — losing excess weight, staying physically active and taking medications available to treat OA pain — there aren’t many other options short of joint replacement. One of these unproven biologic therapies might help fill that treatment gap as long as no evidence-backed alternative exists, says Nicolas Piuzzi, MD, orthopedic surgeon and director of Adult Joint Reconstructive Surgery Research at Cleveland Clinic.

It’s important to manage expectations, though, Dr. Rodeo adds. Insurance typically does not cover these unproven treatments. “I try to explain to the patient that there is a cost outlay. And there is variability in outcome — the degree and duration of relief can be variable. You want the patient to maintain hope but also have realistic expectations.”

Research Challenges

Much more research is needed for these kinds of biological treatments. “It’s clear there is something there because people do seem to get better,” says Dr. Muschler. But numerous variables complicate research and add to the potentially enormous cost of trials to produce a usable product. “There’s huge variation from patient to patient and even from time to time when we make those [biological] preparations,” he says. “What type of patient, what type of comorbidities, what type of disease and how do we manage that variation in lot-to-lot preparation, much less the execution — delivering it to the right place and other factors that influence outcome.”

And how do you measure the cost-benefit in terms of risk as well as financial cost?

“I feel like I would do a disservice to a patient unless I could offer at least a 50% reduction in pain for at least six months and delay their need for surgery a year or longer,” Dr. Muschler says, “because I recognize that the arthroplasty option for OA is a pretty good one, [with a] 95% chance of having an excellent pain result, [and the] average survival of knees now is 30 years. So the idea of providing a therapy that denies them the opportunity to go down that path of predictability, unless it offers them something substantial and predictable, is a challenge.”

And even if regenerative medicines regrow tissue, like cartilage, that doesn’t necessarily mean the patient will experience any improvement in symptoms, Dr. Rodeo says. In fact, there is typically a disconnect between pain a patient feels and the joint damage that imaging, like an X-ray, shows. Plus, the FDA wants to see “real-world” benefits, like improvements in pain and function, before it will consider approving a product, Dr. Bruder adds.

“As we consider this, we won’t know if we are relieving suffering and improving lives unless we collect data before and after, in which patient and over what period of time. So it’s truly necessary to be collecting data to make sure we’re being effective,” Dr. Muschler says.

Randomized control trials, the gold standard in research, would be difficult and costly, but prospective control trials could help shed light on some of the key answers. And registries (databases of patient information) and biorepositories (collections of specimens) can feed research.

Also critical to research: standardized definitions and measures. “What are the markers of quality, purity, potency, whatever it is — which will be different for different tissues? A one-size-fits-all approach doesn’t make sense,” says Dr. Rodeo. “We need much more of a precision-medicine approach, where we can match a tailored therapy to the patient. … We need to define the phenotype of the patient we’re treating, what we put in the patient, what are the patient characteristics and how do we match the two.”

Another complication: Scientists still don’t understand exactly how osteoarthritis happens on a cellular level, so they don’t know exactly what to target as a way to disrupt or slow the disease process, Dr. Piuzzi says.

Future Promise

While there’s a long way to go to having an FDA-approved cell-based biological therapy to treat OA, scientists recognize their promise and continue to lay the groundwork for further, more targeted research.

The Arthritis Foundation can help, forum participants agreed, by continuing to bring together different stakeholders to discuss the challenges and opportunities and to build consensus.

“Bringing people together from different backgrounds is great first step,” says Dr. Piuzzi. It has a unique position in being able to bring patients’ perspective to the table and to deliver data and information that’s important to patients and doctors — such as dispelling common misunderstandings about “stem cell” therapies and other biological treatments for OA.

 

Science
View All Articles
Scientific Professional Sign Up

Stay up-to-date on the latest science funding opportunities, volunteer opportunities and other research collaborations.

Sign Up
Get Involved
  • Live Yes! Arthritis Community
  • Live Yes! Connect Groups
  • Live Yes! Online Community
  • Local Office
  • Fundraising
  • Webinars
  • Volunteer Portal
  • Store
About
  • About Us
  • Annual Report
  • Careers
  • Code Of Ethics
  • Financials
  • News and Stories
  • Privacy Notice
  • Terms of Use
  • Español
Join Us
  • Jingle Bell Run
  • JA Camps
  • Pathways Conference 2023
  • Walk to Cure Arthritis
  • Fundraise Your Way
  • JA Family Summit
Home Office
  • 1355 Peachtree St NE Suite 600
  • Atlanta, GA 30309
  • Helpline: 1.800.283.7800
  • Contact Us
Atlanta, GA
54° Arthritis Index Beneficial
See More Details
Arthritis Foundation is a qualified 501(c)(3) EIN 58-1341679
I Want to Contribute
I Need Help
  • Donate

    Donate

    Every gift to the Arthritis Foundation will help people with arthritis across the U.S. live their best life.

  • Volunteer

    Volunteer

    Join us and become a Champion of Yes. There are many volunteer opportunities available.

  • Live Yes! INSIGHTS

    Live Yes! INSIGHTS

    Take part to be among those changing lives today and changing the future of arthritis.

  • Partner

    Partner

    Proud Partners of the Arthritis Foundation make an annual commitment to directly support the Foundation’s mission.

Donate


Ways to Give

Every gift to the Arthritis Foundation will help people with arthritis across the U.S. live their best life. Whether it is supporting cutting-edge research, 24/7 access to one-on-one support, resources and tools for daily living, and more, your gift will be life-changing.

Make a Donation

Help millions of people live with less pain and fund groundbreaking research to discover a cure for this devastating disease. Please, make your urgently-needed donation to the Arthritis Foundation now!

Become a Member

Become an Arthritis Foundation member today for just $20 and you'll receive access to helpful tools..... and more. 

Make a Honor or Memorial Gift

Honor a loved one with a meaningful donation to the Arthritis Foundation. We'll send a handwritten card to the honoree or their family notifying them of your thoughtful gift.

Gift Planning

I want information on ways to remember the AF in my will, trust or other financial planning vehicles.
 

Other Ways to Give

  • Match Gift
  • Donate a Car
  • Donor-Advised Funds

Volunteer


Volunteer Opportunities

The Arthritis Foundation is focused on finding a cure and championing the fight against arthritis with life-changing information, advocacy, science and community. We can only achieve these goals with your help. Strong, outspoken and engaged volunteers will help us conquer arthritis. By getting involved, you become a leader in our organization and help make a difference in the lives of millions. Join us and become a Champion of Yes.

Become a Volunteer

More About Volunteering

  • Walk to Cure
  • Jingle Bell Run
  • Do it Yourself Fundraising
  • JA Camp
  • Start a Live Yes! Connect Group
  • Be an Online Community Moderator
  • Local Leadership Board

Live Yes! INSIGHTS


Give Just 10 Minutes.

Tell us what matters most to you. Change the future of arthritis.

By taking part in the Live Yes! INSIGHTS assessment, you’ll be among those changing lives today and changing the future of arthritis, for yourself and for 54 million others. And all it takes is just 10 minutes.

Your shared experiences will help:

- Lead to more effective treatments and outcomes
- Develop programs to meet the needs of you and your community
- Shape a powerful agenda that fights for you

Now is the time to make your voice count, for yourself and the entire arthritis community. 

Currently this program is for the adult arthritis community.  Since the needs of the juvenile arthritis (JA) community are unique, we are currently working with experts to develop a customized experience for JA families. 

How are you changing the future?

By sharing your experience, you’re showing decision-makers the realities of living with arthritis, paving the way for change. You’re helping break down barriers to care, inform research and create resources that make a difference in people’s lives, including your own.

Get Started

Partner


Meet Our Partners

As a partner, you will help the Arthritis Foundation provide life-changing resources, science, advocacy and community connections for people with arthritis, the nations leading cause of disability. Join us today and help lead the way as a Champion of Yes.

Trailblazer

Our Trailblazers are committed partners ready to lead the way, take action and fight for everyday victories. They contribute $2,000,000 to $2,749,000

Visionary

Our Visionary partners help us plan for a future that includes a cure for arthritis. These inspired and inventive champions have contributed $1,500,00 to $1,999,999.

Pioneer

Our Pioneers are always ready to explore and find new weapons in the fight against arthritis. They contribute $1,000,000 to $1,499,999.

Pacesetter

Our Pacesetters ensure that we can chart the course for a cure for those who live with arthritis. They contribute $500,000 to $999,000.

Signature

Our Signature partners make their mark by helping us identify new and meaningful resources for people with arthritis. They contribute $250,000 to $499,999.

Supporting

Our Supporting partners are active champions who provide encouragement and assistance to the arthritis community. They contribute $100,000 to $249,999.

More About Partnerships

  • Partner with Us
  • Ease Of Use Commendation
  • Let's Get a Grip On Arthritis
  • Promotions that Give Back